I am sure this book is only purchased by true Outlander fans because the reviews are so poor. Mine is no different and agrees with what everyone has already written. I purchased hoping to get a peek inside Jamie’s perspective when he met Claire but instead was treated to basic writing. Only a few more months until Go Tell the Bees I’m Gone though!!

I was expecting... well as Ms Fitz puts it “a bit more”. This is my first graphic novel but my 9 year old son’s graphic novels seemed pretty detailed so I figured, why not. I don’t recommend buying unless you are a collector.

Loved the story itself! However is a bit overpriced for length of story you get. I'm an avid fan of All things Outlander and Diana's works. But for me this came up a little short. Not because of the story itself I Loved it! Especially from Jamie's perspective and the back stories of Jamie and Murtagh. What I am not a fan of at all is the art work in this book. I had a hard time with it although I knew it was a graphic novel. To me the artwork was to Chinese Cartoonish reminded me of Poke E Man characters. I felt it took away from the feeling of being in Scotland. All in all Im glad read it and enjoyed the story itself and appreciate it being in my collection.

I am a 69 year old reader, my vision has been corrected, glasses. I still have trouble reading the small words contained in the "bubbles". I was extremely disappointed with this book!

Disappointing - This is not a graphic novel, just pictures with some quotes lifted from the novel, haphazardly put together. The art and colours are pretty… but inconsistent, making it hard to tell the differences between characters. Pretty much the only part that is consistent is the colour of Jamie’s hair and Claire. The art rarely flows like graphic novel should, leaving the reader without a sense of progression or the feeling of a story being weaved through art as well as words. The pacing of the writing is atrocious and takes for granted previous knowledge of the novel. If you haven’t read it, this will not make any sense. The frequent and blunt use of thought bubbles and rushed transitions to move the story along - just like you’d find in a child’s comic book - disrupts the flow and pulls you out of the story. I know Galbandon got her break in disney comics - but these techniques abandoned decades ago are out of place and distracting in a modern graphic novel for adults.

The last chapter of this latest book took me by surprise. Having lost a daughter the emotion of Claire and Jamie running to Brianna overpowered me in its simplicity. The sparse use of words for that rejoining of parent to child was perfect. Ms Gabaldon knew that the emotion would be felt as it was by this reader m

The illustrations are terrible -muddy, crude and difficult to tell the difference between characters. Surprising, as its a great story that could be enjoyable in this format. Also, it does not seem possible to increase the font size except by manually pinching out each and every page which is tedious. Think I will stick with the books.

What a tremendous waste of money

It is fun to see the writer's images fleshed out. It is certainly different from my own, but a great way to pass the time while I pass the time waiting for the next installment of the story.

Beautifully illustrated and of course, Jamie's story is compelling-it's Gabaldon doing some of her as usual fine work. It's a shame the folks who gave this such a low rating failed to realize that a Graphic Novel is by definition a story of substantial length which is illustrated. Since Gabaldon has a back-ground in comic books, her venture into Graphic Novels is a pleasant surprise and this offering is an example of one of the best collaborations I've seen; beautiful artwork and wonderful storytelling. I love these characters and having them come to life visually (based on Gabaldon's descriptions) has been an incredible treat.